Is a 401(k) account balance or qualified plan death benefit includible in the gross estate?

Practitioners sometimes cite pre-1984 authority or state-level exclusions as though they eliminate the federal estate tax on qualified plan benefits; they do not. At the federal level, the gross estate includes the full value of qualified plan benefits payable to a named beneficiary after death. The marital deduction under IRC 2056 may offset the estate tax for benefits paid to a surviving spouse, and the unlimited marital deduction eliminates the estate tax on the surviving spouse's share. For benefits paid to non-spouse beneficiaries, no marital deduction is available and the value is included in the taxable estate (subject to the OBBBA $15 million per-person exemption, which may shelter the inclusion for many estates). Roth IRA balances are also includible in the gross estate at date-of-death fair market value, even though qualified Roth distributions are income-tax-free to the beneficiary. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

What is the IRC 691(c) estate tax deduction and how is it calculated for an IRC 2039 annuity inclusion?

The IRC 691(c) deduction is claimed on Schedule A of Form 1040 as a miscellaneous itemized deduction not subject to the 2% floor (it was preserved from the TCJA suspension of miscellaneous itemized deductions). The deduction is only available to beneficiaries who itemize. Beneficiaries who take the standard deduction receive no IRC 691(c) benefit, which means the compressed 10-year distribution timeline under SECURE 2.0 may push the beneficiary into a higher marginal rate without the deduction offset if the beneficiary does not itemize. The calculation spans the entire distribution period: the total IRC 691(c) deduction equals the estate tax attributable to the annuity's gross estate inclusion, allocated pro-rata to each year's IRD recognition. Practitioners should prepare a multi-year deduction tracking schedule for beneficiaries receiving inherited annuities or retirement account distributions. Verify at IRS.gov and confirm with qualified counsel.

How are commercial annuities with survivor riders treated under IRC 2039?

A commercial annuity that was in the pure accumulation phase (not yet annuitized) at the date of death presents a slightly different analysis. If the contract provides for a death benefit to a named beneficiary upon the annuity owner's death before annuitization, the death benefit is typically the greater of the account value and a guaranteed minimum death benefit. The two-part test is still met: the decedent had the right to receive payments (the future annuity stream upon annuitization) and the beneficiary receives a payment (the death benefit) under the same contract. The includible amount is the death benefit value as of the date of death. The death benefit proceeds are IRD because they represent deferred income that the decedent would have recognized as ordinary income upon annuitization. Practitioners should confirm the specific contract terms -- some contracts separate the death benefit into a return-of-premium component (basis) and a gain component (IRD) -- before computing the IRC 691(c) deduction. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

Is deferred compensation an annuity for IRC 2039 purposes, and what is the OBBBA exemption impact?

The OBBBA (One Big Beautiful Budget Act) permanently increased the IRC 2010 basic exclusion amount to $15 million per person, indexed for inflation (verify the current indexed amount at IRS.gov). For most estates, deferred compensation payments included under IRC 2039 will not generate federal estate tax because the total gross estate, including the deferred compensation, remains below the $15 million exemption. However, three consequences survive even when no estate tax is owed: (1) the estate must still file Form 706 if the gross estate plus adjusted taxable gifts exceeds the filing threshold; (2) the deferred compensation payments received by the beneficiary are IRD -- taxable as ordinary income without the IRC 1014 step-up -- regardless of whether estate tax was owed; and (3) the IRC 691(c) deduction is zero (or very small) if no estate tax was attributable to the inclusion, which eliminates or reduces the beneficiary's income tax offset. Verify at IRS.gov before advising.

IRC 2039 Annuities Gross Estate Inclusion Guide

Q: What is the IRC 2039 two-part test for annuity gross estate inclusion?

The two prongs interact in ways that generate common errors. The 'right to receive' prong on the decedent's side captures situations where the decedent never actually received a payment -- for example, a deferred annuity that had not yet annuitized, or a pension that was in the deferral phase at death. The decedent need not have been in pay status; the contractual right to future payments is sufficient. On the survivor's side, the payments must flow under the same contract or agreement -- a separately purchased survivor annuity policy that is contractually distinct from the decedent's annuity may fall outside IRC 2039 (though it may be includible under IRC 2033 as property owned by the decedent, depending on how the policy was structured and funded). Practitioners should map the contractual structure carefully before concluding IRC 2039 does or does not apply. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

Q: How is the commuted value of an annuity calculated for Form 706 Schedule I?

A critical valuation step is confirming what portion of the annuity contract's value is attributable to the survivor benefit versus amounts the decedent had already been paid or amounts that would have passed to the decedent's estate in a non-survivor scenario. Under Treas. Reg. 20.2039-1(b), the gross estate includes the portion of the commuted value of the survivor's payment stream that is proportionate to the consideration contributed by the decedent (and the decedent's employer on the decedent's behalf). If the survivor contributed part of the purchase price independently, only the decedent-funded proportion is includible. Where the entire contract was funded by the decedent or the decedent's employer, the full commuted value of the survivor benefit is includible. Practitioners should obtain the annuity contract and all contribution records to determine the correct proportion. Verify at IRS.gov.

Q: Are Social Security survivor benefits includible in the gross estate under IRC 2039?

The Social Security exclusion creates a common over-inclusion error: practitioners unfamiliar with the exclusion include the commuted value of a surviving spouse's Social Security survivor benefit on Form 706 Schedule I, inflating the gross estate and potentially the estate tax. If a Form 706 has already been filed with a Social Security survivor benefit erroneously included, a protective refund claim or amended return may be warranted. Conversely, the exclusion does not apply to benefits that merely resemble Social Security in structure but are funded differently -- such as certain non-qualified deferred compensation arrangements payable to survivors or private disability and survivor benefit plans. The analysis turns on whether the specific benefit is a Social Security or railroad retirement benefit by statute. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel before filing or amending.

Q: How does SECURE 2.0 affect the gross estate and IRD analysis for inherited annuities?

The SECURE 2.0 interaction with inherited annuities held inside qualified plans adds a layer of complexity: before SECURE 1.0 (2019), a non-spouse beneficiary could stretch distributions over their own life expectancy. Under the 10-year rule, the annuity contract inside the inherited plan must still satisfy the distribution requirements -- meaning the annuity payments must be structured to exhaust the contract within 10 years from the participant's death. Some insurance carriers have modified inherited annuity contract terms to accommodate the 10-year rule, while others have not. If the annuity contract terms cannot conform to the 10-year rule within the plan, the plan could face disqualification risk. Practitioners advising estates with inherited annuities inside qualified plans should confirm the contract terms and carrier's compliance position before the beneficiary makes an irrevocable election. Verify current IRS guidance and plan documents before advising.

Last reviewed: July 2026 | Americas Tax Professional Staff

Written for estate attorneys, CPAs, and enrolled agents advising on estates that include qualified plan benefits, commercial annuities, deferred compensation, or pension survivor benefits.

IRC 2039 is the federal estate tax provision that brings annuity and survivor benefit payments into the decedent's gross estate. It is deceptively simple in structure and consistently misapplied in practice -- in both directions. Some practitioners over-include by pulling Social Security survivor benefits (which are expressly excluded by statute) onto Form 706 Schedule I. Others under-include by overlooking deferred compensation arrangements, pre-annuitization commercial annuity death benefits, or joint-and-survivor pension interests that satisfy the statute's two-part test. After the 1984 repeal of the broad qualified plan exclusion, retirement account balances and pension survivor annuities became fully includible in the gross estate, yet the old exclusion remains in circulation as practitioner folklore. This guide is designed to replace that folklore with the current statutory framework.

Three developments have heightened the importance of getting IRC 2039 right. First, the One Big Beautiful Budget Act (OBBBA) permanently raised the IRC 2010 basic exclusion amount to $15 million per person, which means most estates will owe no federal estate tax -- but the gross estate inclusion still drives the IRC 691(c) income-in-respect-of-a-decedent deduction available to beneficiaries who recognize the annuity income. Second, SECURE 2.0 compressed the distribution timeline for non-eligible designated beneficiaries through the 10-year rule, accelerating IRD recognition and reshaping the 691(c) deduction calculation. Third, commercial annuity products have grown more complex, with layered death benefit guarantees that practitioners must map to the IRC 2039 two-part test before completing Form 706.

The IRC 2039 Two-Part Test: Both Prongs Are Required

IRC 2039(a) includes in the gross estate the value of an annuity or other payment receivable by a beneficiary by reason of surviving the decedent, under any form of contract or agreement, if two conditions are met:

At the time of death, the decedent was receiving an annuity or other payment, OR had the right to receive such payment, either alone or in conjunction with another person; and
The annuity or other payment payable to the beneficiary arises under the same contract or agreement under which the decedent was receiving payments (or held the right to receive payments).

Critical Rule: The Conjunctive Two-Part Test

Both conditions must be satisfied. Miss either prong and IRC 2039 does not apply. The decedent must have been receiving payments OR held a right to receive payments -- the decedent need not have been in pay status at death. A deferred annuity not yet annuitized and a pension not yet in pay phase both satisfy the "right to receive" prong. But if no survivor receives payments under the same contract after the decedent's death, the statute is not triggered at all -- regardless of the value of what the decedent held. Confirm each prong independently before including any amount on Form 706 Schedule I.

Broad Coverage of "Contract or Agreement"

Treas. Reg. 20.2039-1(b)(1) defines "contract or agreement" broadly: it includes not only formal annuity contracts but any plan, arrangement, or understanding -- written or unwritten -- under which the decedent held a right to payments during life and a beneficiary holds a right to payments after death. This captures employer-sponsored qualified and nonqualified plans, deferred compensation agreements, individual retirement accounts, and commercial annuity contracts of all types.

The regulation specifically provides that the two prongs need not be satisfied under a single legal document. If the decedent's right to payments and the survivor's right to payments both arise out of an employment relationship or an employer's plan (even if documented in separate instruments), the arrangement may be treated as a single contract or agreement for IRC 2039 purposes. This is the provision that brings informal salary continuation plans and supplemental executive retirement plans within IRC 2039's reach.

What "Right to Receive" Means

The decedent's prong is satisfied by a right, not just actual receipt. A participant in a defined-contribution plan who died before reaching the plan's normal retirement age had the right to receive a distribution at retirement -- even if no distribution had yet been made. Similarly, the owner of a deferred annuity contract who died during the accumulation phase had the right to annuitize and receive periodic payments. The relevant question is not whether payments had commenced, but whether the contract or arrangement gave the decedent a legally enforceable right to future payments.

Statutory Exclusions from IRC 2039

Amber Alert: Social Security and Railroad Retirement Survivor Benefits Are Excluded

Social Security survivor benefits and railroad retirement survivor benefits are excluded from the gross estate by statute -- they are not subject to IRC 2039 inclusion regardless of the value of the benefit stream. Practitioners who include the commuted value of a surviving spouse's Social Security survivor benefit on Form 706 Schedule I are over-including the gross estate. If a filed Form 706 contains this error, a refund claim or amended return may be appropriate. The exclusion is categorical: it applies to all Social Security and railroad retirement survivor benefits, not just those below a threshold. Verify the current statutory cite at IRS.gov before filing.

The Post-ERISA Repeal of the Qualified Plan Exclusion

Critical Warning: The Qualified Plan Exclusion No Longer Exists at the Federal Level

Many practitioners remember an era when IRC 2039(e) provided a broad exclusion for qualified plan death benefits from the gross estate. That exclusion was repealed by the Deficit Reduction Act of 1984 (DEFRA). After the repeal, Congress did not restore a general federal estate tax exclusion for qualified plan benefits. As of current law, 401(k) balances, 403(b) balances, defined-benefit pension survivor annuities, traditional IRA values at death, and Roth IRA values at death are all includible in the decedent's gross estate under IRC 2039. The "exclusion" many practitioners cite is pre-1984 law. Verify the current statutory state at IRS.gov before advising any client that qualified plan benefits escape the gross estate.

The marital deduction under IRC 2056 remains available to offset the estate tax on qualified plan benefits payable to a surviving spouse, and the unlimited marital deduction eliminates the estate tax on those amounts. But the unlimited marital deduction does not remove the assets from the gross estate for inclusion purposes -- it offsets the tax. For benefits payable to non-spouse beneficiaries, no marital deduction applies. The OBBBA $15 million per-person exemption shelters most estates, but the gross estate value still determines the IRC 691(c) deduction available to beneficiaries.

Commuted Value Calculation and Form 706 Schedule I

Form 706 Schedule I (Annuities) is the reporting vehicle for IRC 2039 inclusions. The estate must list each annuity, pension, or deferred compensation arrangement meeting the two-part test, along with the includible value at the date of death (or alternate valuation date if elected under IRC 2032).

Practitioner Note: Lump Sum vs. Periodic Payment Valuation

If the contract provides for a lump-sum payment to the survivor (such as a 401(k) account balance paid to a named beneficiary), the includible amount equals the lump-sum value at the date of death -- straightforward and definitive. If the contract provides for periodic payments (such as a joint-and-survivor pension annuity), the includible amount is the commuted value of the survivor's anticipated payment stream at the date of death, calculated using IRS actuarial tables from IRS Publication 1457 or a qualified actuary's calculation. Using a wrong valuation method is a common audit trigger. Confirm the contract terms before selecting the valuation approach.

Proportionate Inclusion When the Survivor Contributed

Under Treas. Reg. 20.2039-1(b), the gross estate includes only the proportion of the annuity value attributable to consideration furnished by the decedent (or the decedent's employer). If the survivor contributed to the purchase price of the annuity from independent funds, the survivor's contribution reduces the includible portion. The formula is:

Includible amount = (Decedent's contributions / Total contributions) x Commuted value of survivor's benefit

Where the employer funded the entire benefit on behalf of the employee (as is the case in most qualified defined-benefit plans and employer-sponsored annuities), 100% of the survivor benefit is attributable to the decedent's side and the full commuted value is includible. Where the plan required employee contributions and the survivor is the same employee, the employee's after-tax contributions reduce the includible portion, but the employer's matching contributions are treated as the decedent's contributions.

SECURE 2.0 and Inherited Annuities: The 10-Year Rule Impact

Amber Alert: SECURE 2.0 Compresses IRD Recognition for Inherited Annuities

Under SECURE 2.0, non-eligible designated beneficiaries (generally, beneficiaries other than a surviving spouse, minor child of the participant, disabled or chronically ill individual, or a beneficiary not more than 10 years younger than the participant) must distribute the entire inherited retirement account or qualified annuity within 10 years of the participant's death. This does not change the gross estate inclusion amount under IRC 2039 -- the date-of-death value is still the measure. What it changes is the pace of IRD recognition and therefore the timing and magnitude of the IRC 691(c) deduction. Practitioners must analyze both the estate tax and the income tax consequences together, and must track the deduction across the full 10-year distribution window.

Annuities Inside Qualified Plans and the 10-Year Rule

Annuity contracts held inside qualified plans present an additional complication under SECURE 2.0. The plan must satisfy the required minimum distribution rules, which now require non-eligible designated beneficiaries to exhaust the account within 10 years. Many annuity contracts were not designed to accommodate an accelerated 10-year payout, particularly life-income contracts that were structured to provide lifetime payments. If the contract terms cannot be modified to conform to the 10-year rule within the plan, there is risk of plan disqualification. Practitioners advising estates with inherited annuities should confirm the carrier's compliance position and the plan document's distribution options before the beneficiary makes an irrevocable benefit election.

IRC 691(c) and the Estate Tax Deduction Against IRD Income

The IRC 2039 gross estate inclusion amount is an income in respect of a decedent (IRD) item. The annuity or retirement account value included in the gross estate represents deferred income the decedent would have recognized if received before death. When the beneficiary receives that income, it is taxable as ordinary income -- without any IRC 1014(a) basis step-up (IRC 1014(c) expressly excludes IRD items from the step-up). IRC 691(c) provides partial relief: the beneficiary may deduct the portion of federal estate tax attributable to the IRD inclusion from gross income in the year the IRD is recognized.

Planning Note: IRC 691(c) Deduction Calculation and Tracking

The IRC 691(c) deduction is computed by comparing the actual estate tax to a hypothetical estate tax calculated as if all IRD items (including the IRC 2039-included annuity) were excluded from the gross estate. The difference is the "estate tax attributable to IRD." The beneficiary claims a pro-rata share of this amount as a miscellaneous itemized deduction (not subject to the 2% floor -- this deduction survived the TCJA's suspension of most miscellaneous itemized deductions) in each year IRD income is recognized. Practitioners must prepare a multi-year tracking schedule and confirm the beneficiary itemizes. Under SECURE 2.0's 10-year rule, the deduction is spread across up to 10 years of distributions. If no estate tax was owed (because the estate fell below the OBBBA $15 million exemption), the IRC 691(c) deduction is zero or very small, and the beneficiary receives no income tax offset. The interplay between gross estate size, estate tax owed, and the 691(c) deduction warrants careful analysis before choosing a distribution timeline. Verify at IRS.gov and confirm deduction eligibility with a qualified tax advisor.

Calculating the Pro-Rata Deduction

The pro-rata formula allocates the total IRC 691(c) deduction across each taxable year in which the beneficiary recognizes IRD from the annuity or retirement account. The deduction for any given year equals: (IRD recognized in that year / Total IRD remaining to be recognized) x Total remaining IRC 691(c) deduction attributable to that IRD item. This calculation must be updated each year because the denominator changes as distributions are taken. If the beneficiary receives multiple types of IRD (for example, both an inherited IRA and a deferred compensation payment), the IRC 691(c) deduction is allocated among all IRD items in proportion to their respective contributions to the net estate tax on IRD.

Common Fact Patterns Requiring IRC 2039 Analysis

Joint-and-Survivor Pension Annuities

A defined-benefit pension paid as a joint-and-survivor annuity is the classic IRC 2039 fact pattern. The decedent was in pay status (satisfying prong one), and the surviving spouse receives a reduced benefit for life after the decedent's death (satisfying prong two). The includible amount is the commuted value of the survivor's benefit at the date of death, determined using IRS actuarial tables based on the survivor's age and the benefit amount. Report on Form 706 Schedule I. Because the payment flows to a surviving spouse, the marital deduction under IRC 2056 generally offsets the inclusion in full -- but practitioners should confirm the technical marital deduction requirements are met.

Commercial Annuity with Period-Certain or Survivor Rider

A deferred or immediate commercial annuity that includes a period-certain feature (where payments continue to a beneficiary if the annuitant dies before a fixed term expires) or a joint-and-survivor option satisfies the IRC 2039 two-part test. The beneficiary's payments arise under the same contract as the decedent's annuity. The includible amount for a period-certain annuity is the commuted value of the remaining payments as of the date of death. For a non-annuitized deferred annuity with a death benefit paid to a named beneficiary, the includible amount is the death benefit value -- typically the greater of the account value and any guaranteed minimum death benefit under the contract.

Nonqualified Deferred Compensation and SERPs

A nonqualified deferred compensation agreement that provides for payments to an executive's surviving spouse or beneficiary after the executive's death satisfies the IRC 2039 two-part test if the executive held the right to future payments under the arrangement. Unlike qualified plans, nonqualified deferred compensation is not subject to ERISA and does not benefit from any IRC-level exclusion. The full present value of the survivor's benefit stream is includible in the gross estate. Practitioners should also confirm whether the arrangement is subject to IRC 409A (which governs timing of nonqualified deferred compensation payments) and whether a 409A violation affects the estate's position.

Annuity Type Gross Estate Treatment Reference Table

The following table summarizes the gross estate treatment, valuation basis, IRD character, SECURE 2.0 impact, and Form 706 schedule for common annuity and retirement benefit types that practitioners encounter in estate administration.

Asset Type	Includible Under IRC 2039	Basis for Value	IRD Treatment	SECURE 2.0 Impact	Form 706 Schedule
401(k) account balance	Yes -- full date-of-death value	FMV at death (account balance)	Full IRD; no step-up	10-year rule for non-eligible designated beneficiaries	Schedule I
Traditional IRA	Yes -- full date-of-death value	FMV at death (account balance)	Full IRD; no step-up	10-year rule for non-eligible designated beneficiaries	Schedule I
Roth IRA	Yes -- FMV at death included	FMV at death (account balance)	IRD on earnings; basis returned tax-free	10-year rule applies; qualified Roth distributions remain income-tax-free	Schedule I
Commercial annuity with survivor rider	Yes -- commuted value of survivor's benefit	Commuted value per IRS Publication 1457 or actuary	Gain portion is IRD; basis (investment in contract) returned tax-free	No direct impact if held outside a qualified plan	Schedule I
Joint-and-survivor pension annuity	Yes -- commuted value of survivor's remaining benefit	Commuted value per IRS actuarial tables	Periodic payments are IRD as received	No direct impact; defined-benefit plan rules govern	Schedule I
Nonqualified deferred compensation (SERP / salary continuation)	Yes -- if two-part test met	Present value of survivor's benefit stream	Full IRD as payments received	No 10-year rule; plan terms control timing	Schedule I (or G if treated as general asset)
Social Security survivor benefit	No -- excluded by statute	N/A (excluded)	Not IRD; benefits not income-taxable to survivor	No impact	Not reported on Form 706
Railroad retirement survivor benefit	No -- excluded by statute	N/A (excluded)	Tier 1 treated like Social Security; Tier 2 may be partially taxable	No impact	Not reported on Form 706
Life insurance proceeds (death benefit)	No -- IRC 2042 governs, not IRC 2039	Face amount of policy (under IRC 2042)	Proceeds are generally income-tax-free under IRC 101(a)	No impact	Schedule D (under IRC 2042)
Annuity in pay status to decedent only (no survivor benefit)	No -- second prong not met	N/A (excluded from 2039)	No IRD on the annuity stream itself after death; possible refund of investment in contract	No impact	Not on Schedule I
Inherited annuity (estate of original annuitant)	Yes -- commuted value in original annuitant's estate	Commuted value at original annuitant's death	Payments to successor beneficiary are IRD	10-year rule may apply to successor beneficiary	Schedule I (original annuitant's Form 706)
QTIP trust annuity-like income stream (surviving spouse's interest)	No -- IRC 2044 governs, not IRC 2039	FMV of QTIP trust assets under IRC 2044	Trust income is not IRD; QTIP asset gain may produce IRD on sale	No impact on QTIP; separate from retirement account rules	Schedule F (under IRC 2044)
403(b) account balance	Yes -- full date-of-death value	FMV at death (account balance)	Full IRD; no step-up	10-year rule for non-eligible designated beneficiaries	Schedule I

Form 706 Schedule I: Practitioner Filing Mechanics

Schedule I of Form 706 is titled "Annuities." It must be completed for every annuity, pension, or survivor benefit that the estate is including in the gross estate under IRC 2039. For each item, the practitioner must provide:

A description of the annuity, contract, or plan (including the name of the issuer or plan administrator, the plan type, and the contract number);
The name and relationship of the beneficiary who will receive the payments;
The date the decedent's payments started (or the date the right to payments arose);
The amount of each periodic payment to the decedent (if in pay status) and to the survivor;
The commuted value or lump-sum value as of the date of death (or alternate valuation date if elected);
The proportion includible (the decedent's share of contributions vs. total contributions); and
The includible value after applying the proportionate inclusion formula.

Where an IRS actuarial table is used to compute the commuted value, attach the computation showing the table factors used, the survivor's age, the payment amount, and the resulting commuted value. Where a qualified actuary has been engaged, attach the actuary's certification. Schedule I instructions are updated periodically; verify the current version at IRS.gov before filing.

OBBBA $15 Million Exemption: Impact on IRC 2039 Planning

The One Big Beautiful Budget Act permanently increased the IRC 2010 basic exclusion amount to $15 million per person (indexed for inflation after 2026; verify the current indexed amount at IRS.gov). For a married couple using portability, the combined shelter reaches up to $30 million. The vast majority of estates containing qualified plan benefits, commercial annuities, or pension survivor interests will generate no federal estate tax even after full IRC 2039 inclusion.

The OBBBA context changes the planning conversation in two important respects. First, the primary harm from IRC 2039 inclusion for most clients is no longer the estate tax itself -- it is the loss of the IRC 1014 basis step-up (because IRD items are excluded from the step-up by IRC 1014(c)) combined with the ordinary income tax the beneficiary will owe as distributions are received. The IRC 691(c) deduction provides a partial offset, but only to the extent estate tax was actually paid. For estates well below the $15 million exemption, the 691(c) deduction may be zero, leaving the beneficiary with a full income tax bill on distributions without any deduction offset.

Second, the OBBBA raises the threshold for mandatory Form 706 filing, but practitioners should confirm the current filing threshold at IRS.gov. Even if no estate tax is owed, a Form 706 filing may be required to make a portability election for the surviving spouse's estate -- and that election requires reporting the gross estate in full, including all IRC 2039 inclusions on Schedule I.

Frequently Asked Questions: IRC 2039 Annuities Gross Estate Inclusion

What is the IRC 2039 two-part test for annuity gross estate inclusion?

IRC 2039 applies when (1) the decedent was receiving payments or held the right to receive payments under a contract or agreement, and (2) a beneficiary receives or has the right to receive payments under the same contract after the decedent's death. Both conditions must be met. The decedent need not have been in pay status -- the right to future payments satisfies the first prong. If no survivor receives payments under the same contract, the statute does not apply regardless of the contract's value. Verify at IRS.gov.

Practitioners should separately analyze each contract or arrangement -- not the estate as a whole -- for the two-part test. A retirement account paid as a lump sum to a named beneficiary meets both prongs (the decedent had the right to distributions; the beneficiary receives the lump sum under the same plan documents). A single-life annuity that terminates at the annuitant's death with no survivor benefit satisfies prong one but not prong two -- IRC 2039 does not apply. Verify at IRS.gov.

How is the commuted value of an annuity calculated for Form 706 Schedule I?

For lump-sum survivor payments, the includible amount equals the lump-sum value at the date of death. For periodic survivor payments, use the commuted value computed with IRS actuarial factors from IRS Publication 1457 or a qualified actuary. The key inputs are the survivor's age, the payment amount, the frequency, and the payment term (life, fixed period, or longer of the two). Treas. Reg. 20.2031-7 and 20.2039-1 govern the valuation. Verify current actuarial tables at IRS.gov before filing.

The commuted value must then be adjusted by the proportionate inclusion formula if the survivor contributed independently to the contract's purchase price. The includible amount equals (decedent's contributions divided by total contributions) multiplied by the commuted value. Where the employer funded the entire benefit on the decedent's behalf, 100% of the commuted value is includible. Contributions records from the plan administrator are the starting point for this computation. Verify at IRS.gov.

Is a 401(k) account balance includible in the gross estate under IRC 2039?

Yes. The broad IRC 2039(e) exclusion for qualified plan benefits was repealed by the Deficit Reduction Act of 1984. Under current law, 401(k) account balances, traditional IRA values, Roth IRA values, 403(b) account balances, and pension survivor annuities are all includible in the decedent's gross estate at date-of-death fair market value. The marital deduction under IRC 2056 may offset the inclusion for benefits paid to a surviving spouse, but the inclusion itself is not eliminated. Verify the current statutory state at IRS.gov before advising clients that qualified plan benefits escape the gross estate.

The consequences of inclusion extend beyond estate tax: qualified plan balances are IRD items excluded from the IRC 1014(a) basis step-up by IRC 1014(c). The beneficiary pays ordinary income tax on every distribution without a stepped-up basis. The IRC 691(c) deduction provides a partial income tax offset for the portion of federal estate tax attributable to the IRD inclusion -- but only if estate tax was actually owed. For estates below the OBBBA $15 million exemption where no estate tax is paid, the 691(c) deduction is zero or minimal. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

Are Social Security survivor benefits includible in the gross estate?

No. Social Security survivor benefits and railroad retirement survivor benefits are excluded from the gross estate by statute. The exclusion is categorical -- it applies regardless of the amount of the benefit stream. Practitioners who include the commuted value of a surviving spouse's Social Security survivor benefit on Form 706 Schedule I are overstating the gross estate. A refund claim or amended return may be appropriate if this error appears on a filed Form 706. Verify the current statutory exclusion citation at IRS.gov before completing Schedule I.

The exclusion applies specifically to benefits provided under the Social Security Act and the Railroad Retirement Act. Benefits from private disability or survivor plans that merely resemble Social Security in structure -- but are funded by an employer or a private insurer -- are not covered by the Social Security exclusion. Those arrangements must be analyzed under the IRC 2039 two-part test on their own terms. The label "retirement" or "survivor" does not determine the answer; the statutory source of the benefit does. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

How does SECURE 2.0 affect the IRC 2039 analysis and the IRC 691(c) deduction?

SECURE 2.0 does not change the IRC 2039 gross estate inclusion amount -- the date-of-death fair market value is still the measure. What it changes is the distribution timeline for non-eligible designated beneficiaries, who must now exhaust inherited retirement accounts within 10 years. This compresses IRD recognition into a shorter window, which may push the beneficiary into higher marginal income tax rates in the distribution years and limits flexibility in timing distributions for IRC 691(c) deduction optimization. The estate tax and income tax consequences must be analyzed together before the beneficiary commits to a distribution election. Verify current IRS guidance on the 10-year rule at IRS.gov.

For inherited annuities held inside qualified plans, SECURE 2.0 adds a further complication: the annuity contract terms must be capable of satisfying the 10-year distribution requirement. Some insurance carriers have modified inherited annuity products; others have not. If the annuity contract cannot conform to the 10-year rule within the plan, the plan could face qualification risk. Practitioners should confirm the carrier's position and the plan document's options before the beneficiary makes an irrevocable election. Verify with the plan administrator and current IRS guidance.

What is the IRC 691(c) deduction and how is it calculated for an IRC 2039 annuity inclusion?

IRC 691(c) allows a beneficiary who receives IRD to deduct the federal estate tax attributable to that IRD item in the year the income is recognized. The deduction is computed by comparing the actual estate tax to a hypothetical tax calculated as if all IRD items were excluded from the gross estate. The difference is the estate tax on IRD. For each year the beneficiary recognizes IRD (each distribution year), a pro-rata share of the total IRC 691(c) deduction is claimed. The deduction is a miscellaneous itemized deduction not subject to the 2% floor -- but it requires itemizing. Beneficiaries who take the standard deduction receive no benefit. Verify the deduction computation at IRS.gov and confirm with a qualified tax advisor.

The IRC 691(c) deduction must be tracked across every year the beneficiary recognizes IRD from the inherited annuity or retirement account. The pro-rata allocation is: (IRD recognized in the current year) divided by (total remaining IRD from all sources) multiplied by (total remaining IRC 691(c) deduction). Because the denominator changes each year as distributions are taken, the calculation must be updated annually. Practitioners should prepare a multi-year deduction schedule at the time of estate administration and provide it to the beneficiary. If the estate owed no federal estate tax (because the gross estate was below the OBBBA $15 million exemption), the total IRC 691(c) deduction is zero and no schedule is needed. Verify at IRS.gov.

How are commercial annuity survivor riders treated under IRC 2039?

A commercial annuity with a survivor rider -- whether a joint-and-survivor option, a period-certain feature, or a guaranteed minimum death benefit -- satisfies the IRC 2039 two-part test when the decedent was receiving (or had the right to receive) payments and the rider provides for payments to a named beneficiary after the decedent's death under the same contract. The includible amount is the commuted value of the survivor's benefit at the date of death for periodic-payment riders, or the death benefit amount for lump-sum riders. The gain portion of the payments (above the investment in the contract) is IRD; the investment-in-contract portion is returned to the beneficiary income-tax-free. Verify at IRS.gov.

For a deferred annuity that had not yet annuitized at the time of death, the death benefit payable to the named beneficiary -- typically the contract value or a guaranteed minimum death benefit, whichever is greater -- is includible under IRC 2039. The two-part test is met because the owner had the right to annuitize and receive periodic payments, and the beneficiary receives the death benefit under the same contract. Practitioners should obtain the contract's guaranteed minimum death benefit rider documentation because that benefit may exceed the current account value, particularly after market losses. Verify at IRS.gov and consult qualified counsel.

What is the OBBBA $15 million exemption impact on IRC 2039 planning?

The OBBBA permanently set the IRC 2010 basic exclusion amount at $15 million per person (indexed for inflation; verify the current indexed amount at IRS.gov). For a married couple using the portability election, the combined shelter reaches approximately $30 million. Most estates containing qualified plan balances and commercial annuities will owe no federal estate tax regardless of the IRC 2039 inclusion amount. However, the gross estate inclusion still matters for three reasons: (1) it determines whether Form 706 must be filed (including for portability elections); (2) the included amount has no IRC 1014 basis step-up (IRD items are excluded by IRC 1014(c)); and (3) the IRC 691(c) deduction equals zero for estates that owe no estate tax, leaving beneficiaries with no income tax offset on IRD distributions. Verify at IRS.gov before advising.

Under the OBBBA regime, practitioners advising clients with large retirement accounts and minimal other assets should focus the analysis on the income tax side: beneficiaries will pay ordinary income tax on all traditional IRA and qualified plan distributions without a basis step-up and without a meaningful IRC 691(c) deduction (absent estate tax owed). Strategies for managing the income tax burden -- including qualified charitable distributions, Roth conversions during the decedent's lifetime, and careful timing of distributions within the 10-year window -- deserve the same attention as gross estate computation. The interaction of all three regimes (IRC 2039 inclusion, IRC 691(c) deduction, and SECURE 2.0 distribution rules) makes this a multi-tax-year planning exercise. Consult qualified counsel and verify at IRS.gov.

Need IRC 2039 Annuity Inclusion Analysis for a Pending Estate?

Americas Tax advisors work directly with estate attorneys, CPAs, and enrolled agents on Form 706 Schedule I valuations, IRC 691(c) deduction tracking, and post-SECURE 2.0 distribution planning for inherited retirement accounts and commercial annuities.

Contact Americas Tax Today

IRC 2039 Annuities Gross Estate Inclusion: Survivor Benefit, Commuted Value, and IRD Deduction